Skip to main content

Table 3 The table summarizes major published studies on preoperative conventionally fractionated RT

From: Preoperative hypofractionated radiotherapy for soft tissue sarcomas: a systematic review

Author

Year & country

Type of trial & inclusion criteria

N

Median age (years)

Sex ratio (♀:♂)

Histological grade

Location

Median tumor diameter

Fraction & dose; target volume

EQD2/α/β of 4 Gy

RT modality

CTX

Time to surgery

Median FU (months)

OS

LR

LC

LRFS

DFS

Acute toxicity

Late toxicity

Lansu et al. [65]

2021 Nether-lands

Phase II multi-center trial

Localized extremity or trunk MLPS

79

45

44: 56

N/A

LE: 91%

UE: 3%

Trunk: 6%

9.9 cm

18 × 2 Gy = 36 Gy

CTV = GTV + 3 cm long.; + 1.5 cm all other directions

PTV = CTV + 1 cm

36 Gy/54 Gy

IMRT

No

 ≥ 4 weeks

25

95%

3 yrs

N/A

100%

N/A

N/A

Overall WC; 22%

2°: 11%

3°: 3%

Lansu et al. [66]

2019 Nether-lands

Retrosp. analysis

Localized extremity STS

191

60

♀ n = 88

♂ n = 103

G1: n = 14

G2: n = 76

G3: n = 79

N/A: n = 22

LE: 92%

UE: 8%

N/A

25 × 2 = 50 Gy (85% of pts)

CTV = GTV + 4 cm long.; + 1.5 cm all other directions

PTV = CTV + 1 cm

50 Gy/75 Gy

EBRT

No

6 weeks (median)

21

70% 5 yrs

5%

93% 5 yrs

N/A

N/A

Overall WC: 31%

N/A

Wang et al. [35]

2015 USA

Phase II multi-center trial

Localized extremity STS, < 32 cm

86

61

53: 47

G1: 16.5%

G2: 26.6%

G3: 48.1%

LE: 78.5%

UE: 13.9%

Other: 7.6%

10.5 cm

25 × 2 Gy = 50 Gy

PTV = CTV + 0.5 cm

 ≥ 8 cm diameter or G2/G3: CTV = GTV + 3 cm long.; + 1.5 cm radial

 < 8 cm diameter or G1

CTV = GTV + 2 cm long., 1 cm radial

50 Gy/75 Gy

IG-IMRT 74.7%

3DCRT 25.3%

No

4–8 weeks

3.6 yrs

80.6% 2 yrs

N/A

94% 2 yrs

N/A

N/A

Major WC: 36.6%

 ≥ 2°: 10.5% at 2 yrs

O’Sullivan et al. [67]

2013 Canada

Phase II single center trial Localized lower extremity STS

59

56 (mean)

♀n = 29 ♂n = 30

G1: n = 4

G2: n = 26

G3: n = 29

LE only

9.5 cm

25 × 2 Gy = 50 Gy

CTV = GTV + 4 cm long. + 1.5 cm radial

PTV = CTV + 0.5 cm

50 Gy/75 Gy

IG-IMRT

No

N/A

49

N/A

6.8%

N/A

88.2% 5 yrs

N/A

Major WC: 30.5%

No > 2° toxicity

Hui et al. [68]

2006 Australia

Retrosp. analysis

Localized extremity or trunk wall STS

67

52

♀n = 26 ♂n = 41

G1: n = 19

G2/G3: n = 46

N/A: n = 2

LE: n = 53

UE: n = 9

Trunk: n = 5

6 cm

28 × 1.8 Gy = 50.4 Gy

PTV = GTV + 6 cm long.

48.72 Gy/73.08 Gy

EBRT

n = 3 pts: doxo post op

33 days (median)

4.1 yrs

73% 5 yrs

9%

N/A

93% 5 yrs

N/A

3°: Dermatitis: 6%

overall WC: 41%

Overall: n = 5 pts

Kraybill et al. [69]

2006 USA

Phase II multi-center trial

G2–G3 extremity and trunk wall sarcoma, ≥ 8 cm, ≤ 4 lung metastases

64

45.5

44: 56

G2: 20%

G3: 80%

Extremity 88%

Torso: 12%

15 cm

22 × 2 Gy interdigitated = 44 Gy

PTV = GTV + 9 cm long. +  ≥ 2 cm radial

44 Gy/66 Gy

EBRT

MAID

80 days after day 1 of CTX

6.1 yrs

75.1% 3 yrs

17.6% 3 yrs

N/A

N/A

56.6% 3 yrs

3°: Hematological: 13%

Nonhematological: 28%

4°: Overall: 84%

5°: Overall: 5%

Late toxicity: N/A

Zagars et al. [70]

2003 USA

Retrosp. Analysis

Localized, G1–G3 STS

271 pre op

N/A

N/A

G1: 4%

G2: 26%

G3: 70%

LE: 59%

UE: 14%

Other: 27%

8 cm

Median single dose: 2.0 Gy

Median total dose: 50 Gy

50 Gy/75 Gy

EBRT

doxo

4–6 weeks

6.4 yrs

N/A

N/A

85% 5 yrs

83% 10 yrs

N/A

N/A

N/A

5%

O’ Sullivan et al. [25, 26] and Davis et al. [24]

2002 Canada

Phase III multi-center RCT

Localized, extremity STS

94 pre op

 < 50: 34%

 ≥ 50– < 70: 43%

 ≥ 70: 23%

45: 55

G1: 17%

G2–G3: 83%

LE: 80%

UE: 20%

 ≤ 10 cm 65%

 > 10 cm 35%

Pre op: 25 × 2 Gy = 50 Gy (n = 88 pts)

Additional post op boost 8 × 2 Gy = 16 Gy (n = 14 pts)

pre op PTV = GTV + 5 cm long.

Post op boost: PTV = GTV + 2 cm

Pre op: 50 Gy/75 Gy

post op boost: 16 Gy/24 Gy

EBRT

No

3–6 weeks

3.3 yrs

73%

N/A

93% 5 yrs

58% 5 yrs

N/A

Major WC: 35%

 ≥ 2°:

Fibrosis: 31.5% Joint stiffness: 17.8%

Edema: 15.1%

Pollack et al. [71]

1998 USA

Retrosp. analysis

G2–G3 pleom. sarcoma, liposarcoma, synovial sarcoma

128 pre op

54 (mean)

58: 42

G2: 32.8%

G3: 67.2%

LE + UE: 82%

Other: 18%

10 cm (mean)

25 × 2 Gy = 50 Gy

PTV = GTV + 5–7 cm long. + 2–3 cm radial

50 Gy/75 Gy

3D-CRT

doxo, CP, DTIC, VCR

N/A

97

N/A

N/A

82% 5 yrs

N/A

N/A

Acute WC: 25% (pre op)

6.2% (entire cohort)

  1. The trial characteristics, patient characteristics, radiotherapy, chemotherapy, time to surgery as well as outcome parameters and rates for acute and late toxicity are included. 1° (grade 1), 2° (grade 2), 3° (grade 3), 3D-CRT (3D conformal radiotherapy), BED (Biologically Effective Dose), cm (centimeter), CP (cyclophosphamide) CTV (clinical target volume), CTX (chemotherapy), DFS (disease-free survival), doxo (doxorubicine), DTIC (dacarbazine), EBRT (external beam radiotherapy), EQD2 (Equivalent Dose in 2 Gy Fractions), FU (follow-up), G (grade), GTV (gross tumor volume), Gy (gray), IMRT (intensity modulated radiotherapy), IG-IMRT (Image-guided intensity-modulated radiotherapy), LC (local control), LE (lower extremity), long. (longitudinally), LR (local recurrence), LRFS (local recurrence-free survival), MLPS (myxoid liposarcoma), mths (months), N/A (not available), OS (overall survival), pts (patients),  pre op (preoperative), post op (postoperative), PTV (planning target volume), RCT (randomized controlled trial), Retrosp. analysis (retrospective analysis), RT (radiotherapy), STS (soft tissue sarcoma), transv (transversally), UE (upper extremity), USA (United States of America), VCR (vincristine), VMAT (Volumetric Intensity Modulated Arc Therapy), WC (wound complication), yrs (years)