From: Preoperative hypofractionated radiotherapy for soft tissue sarcomas: a systematic review
Author | Year & country | Type of trial & inclusion criteria | N | Median age (years) | Sex ratio (♀:♂) | Histological grade | Location | Median tumor diameter | Fraction & dose; target volume | EQD2/α/β of 4 Gy | RT modality | CTX | Time to surgery | Median FU (months) | OS | LR | LC | LRFS | DFS | Acute toxicity | Late toxicity |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Lansu et al. [65] | 2021 Nether-lands | Phase II multi-center trial Localized extremity or trunk MLPS | 79 | 45 | 44: 56 | N/A | LE: 91% UE: 3% Trunk: 6% | 9.9 cm | 18 × 2 Gy = 36 Gy CTV = GTV + 3 cm long.; + 1.5 cm all other directions PTV = CTV + 1 cm | 36 Gy/54 Gy | IMRT | No |  ≥ 4 weeks | 25 | 95% 3 yrs | N/A | 100% | N/A | N/A | Overall WC; 22% | 2°: 11% 3°: 3% |
Lansu et al. [66] | 2019 Nether-lands | Retrosp. analysis Localized extremity STS | 191 | 60 | ♀ n = 88 ♂ n = 103 | G1: n = 14 G2: n = 76 G3: n = 79 N/A: n = 22 | LE: 92% UE: 8% | N/A | 25 × 2 = 50 Gy (85% of pts) CTV = GTV + 4 cm long.; + 1.5 cm all other directions PTV = CTV + 1 cm | 50 Gy/75 Gy | EBRT | No | 6 weeks (median) | 21 | 70% 5 yrs | 5% | 93% 5 yrs | N/A | N/A | Overall WC: 31% | N/A |
Wang et al. [35] | 2015 USA | Phase II multi-center trial Localized extremity STS, < 32 cm | 86 | 61 | 53: 47 | G1: 16.5% G2: 26.6% G3: 48.1% | LE: 78.5% UE: 13.9% Other: 7.6% | 10.5 cm | 25 × 2 Gy = 50 Gy PTV = CTV + 0.5 cm  ≥ 8 cm diameter or G2/G3: CTV = GTV + 3 cm long.; + 1.5 cm radial  < 8 cm diameter or G1 CTV = GTV + 2 cm long., 1 cm radial | 50 Gy/75 Gy | IG-IMRT 74.7% 3DCRT 25.3% | No | 4–8 weeks | 3.6 yrs | 80.6% 2 yrs | N/A | 94% 2 yrs | N/A | N/A | Major WC: 36.6% |  ≥ 2°: 10.5% at 2 yrs |
O’Sullivan et al. [67] | 2013 Canada | Phase II single center trial Localized lower extremity STS | 59 | 56 (mean) | ♀n = 29 ♂n = 30 | G1: n = 4 G2: n = 26 G3: n = 29 | LE only | 9.5 cm | 25 × 2 Gy = 50 Gy CTV = GTV + 4 cm long. + 1.5 cm radial PTV = CTV + 0.5 cm | 50 Gy/75 Gy | IG-IMRT | No | N/A | 49 | N/A | 6.8% | N/A | 88.2% 5 yrs | N/A | Major WC: 30.5% | No > 2° toxicity |
Hui et al. [68] | 2006 Australia | Retrosp. analysis Localized extremity or trunk wall STS | 67 | 52 | ♀n = 26 ♂n = 41 | G1: n = 19 G2/G3: n = 46 N/A: n = 2 | LE: n = 53 UE: n = 9 Trunk: n = 5 | 6 cm | 28 × 1.8 Gy = 50.4 Gy PTV = GTV + 6 cm long. | 48.72 Gy/73.08 Gy | EBRT | n = 3 pts: doxo post op | 33 days (median) | 4.1 yrs | 73% 5 yrs | 9% | N/A | 93% 5 yrs | N/A | 3°: Dermatitis: 6% overall WC: 41% | Overall: n = 5 pts |
Kraybill et al. [69] | 2006 USA | Phase II multi-center trial G2–G3 extremity and trunk wall sarcoma, ≥ 8 cm, ≤ 4 lung metastases | 64 | 45.5 | 44: 56 | G2: 20% G3: 80% | Extremity 88% Torso: 12% | 15 cm | 22 × 2 Gy interdigitated = 44 Gy PTV = GTV + 9 cm long. +  ≥ 2 cm radial | 44 Gy/66 Gy | EBRT | MAID | 80 days after day 1 of CTX | 6.1 yrs | 75.1% 3 yrs | 17.6% 3 yrs | N/A | N/A | 56.6% 3 yrs | 3°: Hematological: 13% Nonhematological: 28% 4°: Overall: 84% 5°: Overall: 5% Late toxicity: N/A | |
Zagars et al. [70] | 2003 USA | Retrosp. Analysis Localized, G1–G3 STS | 271 pre op | N/A | N/A | G1: 4% G2: 26% G3: 70% | LE: 59% UE: 14% Other: 27% | 8 cm | Median single dose: 2.0 Gy Median total dose: 50 Gy | 50 Gy/75 Gy | EBRT | doxo | 4–6 weeks | 6.4 yrs | N/A | N/A | 85% 5 yrs 83% 10 yrs | N/A | N/A | N/A | 5% |
2002 Canada | Phase III multi-center RCT Localized, extremity STS | 94 pre op |  < 50: 34%  ≥ 50– < 70: 43%  ≥ 70: 23% | 45: 55 | G1: 17% G2–G3: 83% | LE: 80% UE: 20% |  ≤ 10 cm 65%  > 10 cm 35% | Pre op: 25 × 2 Gy = 50 Gy (n = 88 pts) Additional post op boost 8 × 2 Gy = 16 Gy (n = 14 pts) pre op PTV = GTV + 5 cm long. Post op boost: PTV = GTV + 2 cm | Pre op: 50 Gy/75 Gy post op boost: 16 Gy/24 Gy | EBRT | No | 3–6 weeks | 3.3 yrs | 73% | N/A | 93% 5 yrs | 58% 5 yrs | N/A | Major WC: 35% |  ≥ 2°: Fibrosis: 31.5% Joint stiffness: 17.8% Edema: 15.1% | |
Pollack et al. [71] | 1998 USA | Retrosp. analysis G2–G3 pleom. sarcoma, liposarcoma, synovial sarcoma | 128 pre op | 54 (mean) | 58: 42 | G2: 32.8% G3: 67.2% | LE + UE: 82% Other: 18% | 10 cm (mean) | 25 × 2 Gy = 50 Gy PTV = GTV + 5–7 cm long. + 2–3 cm radial | 50 Gy/75 Gy | 3D-CRT | doxo, CP, DTIC, VCR | N/A | 97 | N/A | N/A | 82% 5 yrs | N/A | N/A | Acute WC: 25% (pre op) | 6.2% (entire cohort) |