Skip to main content

Table 2 Results. The table summarizes the current literature on preoperative hypofractionated RT for STS

From: Preoperative hypofractionated radiotherapy for soft tissue sarcomas: a systematic review

Author

Year and country

Type of trial and inclusion criteria

N

Median age (years)

Sex ratio (♀:♂ in %)

Histologic grade

Location

Median tumor diameter

Fraction and dose; target Volume

EQD2/BEDα/β of 4 (Gy)

Koseła-Paterczyk et al. [53]

2021 Poland

Phase II single center trial

Localized G2-G3 STS or G1 if >10cm

311

57

52 : 48

G1-2: 9.7%

G3: 84.1%

Unknown: 6.2%

LE: 72%

UE: 16.7%

Trunk: 11.3%

10 cm

5 x 5 Gy = 25 Gy

CTV = GTV + 2cm transv.; + 4cm long.

PTV = CTV + 0.7-1cm

37.5 Gy/ 56.3 Gy

Spalek et al. [54]

2021 Poland

Phase II single center trial

Localized, marginally resectable G2-G3 STS

46

58

37 : 63

G2: 34.8%

G3: 65.2%

LE: 63%

UE: 15%

Trunk: 22%

17.4 cm

5 x 5 Gy = 25 Gy

CTV = GTV + 2cm transv.; + 4cm long.

PTV = CTV + 0.7-1cm

37.5 Gy/ 56.3 Gy

Leite et al. [55]

2021 Brazil

Phase II single center trial

Localized, extremity G2-G3 STS > 10 cm

25

42

44 : 56

G1-2: 21.7%

G3: 78.3 %

LE: 60%

UE: 40%

14 cm Pre-SBRT

10.5 cm Post-SBRT

5 x 8 Gy = 40 Gy

CTV = GTV + 0.3-0.5 cm radial;

+ 2-3 cm long. PTV = CTV + 0.3cm

80 Gy/120 Gy

Potkrajcic et al. [56]

2021 Germany

Retrosp. Analysis

Age >75 yrs., G2-G3 STS, localized on extremity/trunk

18

83.7

N/A

G2: 33.3%

G3: 55.6%

G2-3: 5.6%

Unknown: 5.6%

LE: 55.6%

UE: 27.8%

Trunk: 16.6%

7.9 cm

5 x 5 Gy = 25 Gy

CTV = GTV + 1.5cm radial; + 3cm long.

PTV = CTV + 0.5-1 cm

37.5 Gy/ 56.3 Gy

Silva et al. [57]

2021 Brazil

Phase II single center trial

Age 18-75, localized STS, not amenable to resection

18

53.5

56 : 44

G2: 11%

G3: 89%

LE: 67%

UE: 33%

8.9 cm

5 x 5 Gy = 25 Gy

CTV = GTV + 1.5cm radial; + 4cm long.

PTV = CTV + 1cm

37.5 Gy/ 56.3 Gy

RT modality

CTX

Time to surgery

Median FU (mths)

OS

LR

LC

LRFS

DFS

Acute toxicity

Late toxicity

3D-CRT: 95.8% IMRT: 3.9%

VMAT: 0.3 %

IGRT: 100%

30.2 % pre-OP AI or doxo/DTIC

2-4 days

57.3

63%

5 yrs

13.8%

5 yrs

N/A

N/A

46%

5 yrs.

Major WC: 24%:

Overall: 8.6%

3D-CRT: 6.5%

VMAT: 41.3%

IMRT: 52.2%

IGRT: 100%

AI 3 cycles

6-8 weeks

24.4

53%

3 yrs

3 of 41 resected tumors (7%)

N/A

67%

2 yrs

N/A

Major WC: 34%.

Overall: °1-°4: 44%

pending

SBRT

IMRT

VMAT

IGRT

20% pre-op

8.6 weeks (median)

20.7

≈ 85%

3 yrs

0%

2 yrs

N/A

≈ 85%

3 yrs

N/A

Major WC: 28%

2°: Dermatitis: 48%

Edema: 8%

3° Dermatitis:20%

1°: Fibrosis: 34.7%

Edema: 21.7%

2°: Fibrosis: 4.3%

Edema: 4.3%

Stiffness: 13%

3D-CRT > IMRT/ VMAT

No

4.1 weeks (median)

5.1

100%

2 of 17 followed pts (11.8%)

92%

6 mths

N/A

84% 6 mths

Major WC: 29%

N/A

3D-CRT IMRT

AI 3 cycles

6 weeks (median)

29

95%

N/A

95%

N/A

72%

Major WC: 33%

1°: Fibrosis: 50%

Stiffness: 16%

Edema: 11%

2°: Fibrosis: 6%

Stiffness: 6%

Edema: 11%

Author

Year and country

Type of trial and Inclusion criteria

N

Median age (years)

Sex ratio (♀:♂ in %)

Histologic grade

Location

Median tumor diameter

Fraction and dose; target volume

EQD2/BEDα/β of 4 (Gy)

Koseła-Paterczyk et al. [58]

2020 Poland

Phase II single center trial

Localized extremity or trunk MLPS, ≥ 5cm

27

43

48 : 52

Myxoid liposarcoma only

G1-G2: 66.6%

G3: 33.3%

LE only

13 cm

5 x 5 Gy = 25 Gy

CTV = GTV + 2cm transv.; +4cm long.

PTV = CTV + 0.7-1cm

37.5 Gy/ 56.3 Gy

Kalbasi et al. [47]

2020 USA

Phase II single center trial

Localized extremity or trunk STS

50

<50: 28% 50-64:

22% 65-79: 40%

>79: 10%

44 : 56

G1: 2 %

G2: 38 %

G3: 60 %

LE: 68%

UE: 18%

Trunk: 14%

26% ≤5 cm 50% >5 -

≤10 cm 24%

>10 cm:

5 x 6 Gy = 30 Gy

CTV = GTV + 1.5cm transv.; + 3cm long.

PTV = CTV + 0.5cm

50 Gy/75 Gy

Parsai et al. [59]

2020 USA

Retrosp. Analysis Localized extremity or trunk STS

16

64

44 : 56

G2: 50%

G3: 18.8%

Unknown: 31.2%

LE: 62.5%

UE: 25%

Trunk: 12.5%

18.8% ≤5 cm 56.2%

>5 - ≤10cm 18.8%

>10 cm - ≤15 cm

6.2% >15 cm

n=1: 5 x 5 Gy = 25 Gy

n=14: 5 x 6 Gy = 30 Gy

n=1 5 x 8 Gy = 40 Gy

Target volumes: according to RTOG-0630 [35]

n=1

37.5 Gy/ 56.3 Gy

n=14

50 Gy/75 Gy

n=1

80 Gy/120 Gy

Pennington et al. [60]

2018 USA

Retrosp. Analysis Localized, non-recurrent STS

116

46

40 : 60

G1: 0.9%

G2: 13%

G3: 79%

Unknown: 7%

LE: 79%

UE: 21%

17% ≤5cm 35%

>5 - ≤10 cm

47% >10 cm

8 x 3.5 Gy = 28 Gy

CTV = GTV + 4-5 cm long.

PTV: N/A

35 Gy/52.5 Gy

RT modality

CTX

Time to surgery

Median FU (mths)

OS

LR

LC

LRFS

DFS

Acute toxicity

Late toxicity

3D-CRT > IMRT > VMAT

No

7 weeks (median)

27.1

25 of 27 pts (93%)

0%

N/A

N/A

100% 3 yrs G1-G2 50% 3 yrs G3

Wound dehiscence: 10.3%

Wound infection: 17.2%

Dermatitis: 1°: 34.4%

2°: 3.4%

3°: 3.4%

13.8 %

Edema:

1°: 3.4%

2°: 3.4%

Fibrosis

°1: 3.4%

°2: 3.4%

3D-CRT 20

IMRT 76%

IGRT 96%

Electron 4%

No

4 weeks (median)

29

84%

2 of 35 pts (5.7%)

N/A

N/A

N/A

Major WC: 32%

Most common in LE

°2 dermatitis: 8%

1°: Fibrosis: 24%

Stiffness: 11%

Edema: 4%

2°: Fibrosis: 11%

Stiffness: 11%

Edema: 4%

IMRT

VMAT

IGRT

N = 2 pts*

1 day (median)

10.7

87.5%

0%

N/A

N/A

N/A

Major WC: 18.8%

Minor WC: 12.5%

≥3°: 0%

3D-CRT

AI

1-2

weeks

5.9 yrs

82% 3 yrs

67% 6 yrs

11% 3 yrs

17% 6 yrs

N/A

N/A

N/A

Toxicity recorded for 17 pts:

Acute WC:

seromas/hematomas: 6

surgical site infection: 5

delayed wound healing: 1

Author

Year and country

Type of trial and Inclusion criteria

N

Median age (years)

Sex ratio (♀:♂ in %)

Histologic grade

Location

Median tumor dia- meter

Fraction and dose; target volume

EQD2/BEDα/β of 4 (Gy)

Kubicek et al. [61]

2018 USA

Phase II single center trial

Localized extremity STS

13

N/A, all patients > 18 yrs

N/A

G1-G2: 21.4%

G3: 78.5%

LE: 71.4%

UE: 14.3%

Groin: 14.3%

7.6 cm

Most pts: 5 x 7 Gy = 35 Gy

3 of 13 pts: 5 x 8 Gy = 40 Gy

Median isodose line: 81%

CTV = GTV + 0.5 cm radial; + 3 cm long. PTV= CTV + 0.5 cm

Most pts: 64.17 Gy/96.3 Gy

3 of 13 pts:

80 Gy/120 Gy

Kılıç et al. [62]

2017 Turkey

Retrosp. Analysis

Localized, G2-G3

≥ 4cm or G1 ≥ 8cm extremity STS

67

47

43 : 57

G2: 7.5%

G3: 26.9 %

Unknown: 65.6%

N/A

9.6 cm

8 x 3.5 Gy = 28 Gy

PTV: N/A

35 Gy/52.5 Gy

Koseła-Paterczyk et al. [63]

2016 Poland

Sub-analysis of (64)

32

50

41 : 59

Myxoid liposarcoma only

G1: 15.6 %

G2: 12.5 %

G3: 46.9 %

Unknown: 25%

LE: 97%

UE: 3%

10.5 cm

53%: 5 x 5 Gy = 25 Gy

47%: 5 x 4 Gy = 20 Gy

CTV = GTV + 2cm transv.; + 4cm long.

PTV = CTV + 0.7-1cm

53%: 37.5 Gy/ 56.3 Gy

47%: 26.67 Gy/40 Gy

Koseła-Paterczyk et al. [64]

2014 Poland

Phase II single center trial

Locally advanced trunk wall or extremity G2-G3 STS or G1 if > 10cm diameter

272

55

53 : 47

G1: 11.8 %

G2: 23.6 %

G3: 64.6 %

LE: 70.2%

UE: 16.2%

Trunk: 13.6%

8.5 cm

5 x 5 Gy = 25 Gy

CTV = GTV + 2cm transv.; + 4cm long.

PTV = CTV + 0.7-1cm

37.5 Gy/ 56.3 Gy

RT modality

CTX

Time to surgery

Median FU (months)

OS

LR

LC

LRFS

DFS

Acute toxicity

Late toxicity

SBRT

21.4%; agent N/A

37 days (median)

279 days

N/A

7.7%

93%

N/A

N/A

Major WC: 28.5 %

0%

N/A

50% RT+AI vs. 50% RT alone

2-3 Weeks after pre-op RT

37

3yrs: 74.1% vs. 90.0% p=0.4

14.9%

N/A

3 yrs: 77.1% vs. 76.3%

p=0.86

3 yrs: 50.5% vs. 65.7%

p=0.33

N/A

N/A

3D-CRT

No

3-7 days

60

68% 5 yrs

9.3%

90%# 5 yrs

N/A#

N/A

Acute:22 % = 7 patients

3 wound infection

2 wound dehiscence

5 prolonged healing

Late: 9% = 3 patients

1 prolonged edema

2 tissue fibrosis

No differences in RT regimens

3D-CRT IMRT for trunk lesions only (13.6%)

22.4% substance N/A

3-7 days

35

72% 3 yrs

19.1%

81% 3yrs**

N/A**

N/A

Overall: 32.4%: Inflammation requiring antibiotic treatment: 11.8%

Wound dehiscence: 11.8%

Prolonged wound healing: 16.5%

Overall: 14.7% 1°-3°

Fibrosis: 3.7%

Edema: 9.2%

  1. The trial characteristics, patient characteristics, radiotherapy, chemotherapy, time to surgery as well as outcome parameters and rates for acute and late toxicity are included. 1° (grade 1), 2° (grade 2), 3° (grade 3), 3D-CRT (3D conformal radiotherapy), AI (doxorubicin/ifosfamide), BED (Biologically Effective Dose), cm (centimeter), CTV (clinical target volume), CTX (chemotherapy), DFS (disease-free survival), doxo (doxorubicine), DTIC (dacarbazine), EQD2 (Equivalent Dose in 2 Gy Fractions), FU (follow-up), G (grade), GTV (gross tumor volume), Gy (gray), IGRT (image-guided radiotherapy), IMRT (intensity modulated radiotherapy), LC (local control), LE (lower extremity), long. (longitudinally), (LR (local recurrence), LRFS (local recurrence-free survival), mths (months), N/A (not available), OS (overall survival), pts (patients), PTV (planning target volume) Retrosp. Analysis (retrospective analysis), RT (radiotherapy), SBRT (stereotactic body radiotherapy), STS (soft tissue sarcoma), transv (transversally), UE (upper extremity), USA (United States of America), VMAT (Volumetric Intensity Modulated Arc Therapy), WC (wound complication), yrs (years)
  2. *One patient received gemcitabine/docetaxel 6 weeks post-op; one patient received doxorubicin/temsirolimus 1 week prior to RT
  3. #The definition of LRFS included the events local recurrence or death. Notably, the trial applied the same definition, however, the value of 90% for 5-year LRFS is higher than the 5-year OS of 68%, which counters the definition of LRFS. The 5-year 90% value is therefore equivalent to the 5-year local control
  4. **Death was not included as an event for the LRFS. The 81% is therefore equivalent to the 3-year LC rate