From: Preoperative hypofractionated radiotherapy for soft tissue sarcomas: a systematic review
Author | Year and country | Type of trial and inclusion criteria | N | Median age (years) | Sex ratio (♀:♂ in %) | Histologic grade | Location | Median tumor diameter | Fraction and dose; target Volume | EQD2/BEDα/β of 4 (Gy) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Koseła-Paterczyk et al. [53] | 2021 Poland | Phase II single center trial Localized G2-G3 STS or G1 if >10cm | 311 | 57 | 52 : 48 | G1-2: 9.7% G3: 84.1% Unknown: 6.2% | LE: 72% UE: 16.7% Trunk: 11.3% | 10 cm | 5 x 5 Gy = 25 Gy CTV = GTV + 2cm transv.; + 4cm long. PTV = CTV + 0.7-1cm | 37.5 Gy/ 56.3 Gy |
Spalek et al. [54] | 2021 Poland | Phase II single center trial Localized, marginally resectable G2-G3 STS | 46 | 58 | 37 : 63 | G2: 34.8% G3: 65.2% | LE: 63% UE: 15% Trunk: 22% | 17.4 cm | 5 x 5 Gy = 25 Gy CTV = GTV + 2cm transv.; + 4cm long. PTV = CTV + 0.7-1cm | 37.5 Gy/ 56.3 Gy |
Leite et al. [55] | 2021 Brazil | Phase II single center trial Localized, extremity G2-G3 STS > 10 cm | 25 | 42 | 44 : 56 | G1-2: 21.7% G3: 78.3 % | LE: 60% UE: 40% | 14 cm Pre-SBRT 10.5 cm Post-SBRT | 5 x 8 Gy = 40 Gy CTV = GTV + 0.3-0.5 cm radial; + 2-3 cm long. PTV = CTV + 0.3cm | 80 Gy/120 Gy |
Potkrajcic et al. [56] | 2021 Germany | Retrosp. Analysis Age >75 yrs., G2-G3 STS, localized on extremity/trunk | 18 | 83.7 | N/A | G2: 33.3% G3: 55.6% G2-3: 5.6% Unknown: 5.6% | LE: 55.6% UE: 27.8% Trunk: 16.6% | 7.9 cm | 5 x 5 Gy = 25 Gy CTV = GTV + 1.5cm radial; + 3cm long. PTV = CTV + 0.5-1 cm | 37.5 Gy/ 56.3 Gy |
Silva et al. [57] | 2021 Brazil | Phase II single center trial Age 18-75, localized STS, not amenable to resection | 18 | 53.5 | 56 : 44 | G2: 11% G3: 89% | LE: 67% UE: 33% | 8.9 cm | 5 x 5 Gy = 25 Gy CTV = GTV + 1.5cm radial; + 4cm long. PTV = CTV + 1cm | 37.5 Gy/ 56.3 Gy |
RT modality | CTX | Time to surgery | Median FU (mths) | OS | LR | LC | LRFS | DFS | Acute toxicity | Late toxicity |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
3D-CRT: 95.8% IMRT: 3.9% VMAT: 0.3 % IGRT: 100% | 30.2 % pre-OP AI or doxo/DTIC | 2-4 days | 57.3 | 63% 5 yrs | 13.8% 5 yrs | N/A | N/A | 46% 5 yrs. | Major WC: 24%: | Overall: 8.6% |
3D-CRT: 6.5% VMAT: 41.3% IMRT: 52.2% IGRT: 100% | AI 3 cycles | 6-8 weeks | 24.4 | 53% 3 yrs | 3 of 41 resected tumors (7%) | N/A | 67% 2 yrs | N/A | Major WC: 34%. Overall: °1-°4: 44% | pending |
SBRT IMRT VMAT IGRT | 20% pre-op | 8.6 weeks (median) | 20.7 | ≈ 85% 3 yrs | 0% 2 yrs | N/A | ≈ 85% 3 yrs | N/A | Major WC: 28% 2°: Dermatitis: 48% Edema: 8% 3° Dermatitis:20% | 1°: Fibrosis: 34.7% Edema: 21.7% 2°: Fibrosis: 4.3% Edema: 4.3% Stiffness: 13% |
3D-CRT > IMRT/ VMAT | No | 4.1 weeks (median) | 5.1 | 100% | 2 of 17 followed pts (11.8%) | 92% 6 mths | N/A | 84% 6 mths | Major WC: 29% | N/A |
3D-CRT IMRT | AI 3 cycles | 6 weeks (median) | 29 | 95% | N/A | 95% | N/A | 72% | Major WC: 33% | 1°: Fibrosis: 50% Stiffness: 16% Edema: 11% 2°: Fibrosis: 6% Stiffness: 6% Edema: 11% |
Author | Year and country | Type of trial and Inclusion criteria | N | Median age (years) | Sex ratio (♀:♂ in %) | Histologic grade | Location | Median tumor diameter | Fraction and dose; target volume | EQD2/BEDα/β of 4 (Gy) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Koseła-Paterczyk et al. [58] | 2020 Poland | Phase II single center trial Localized extremity or trunk MLPS, ≥ 5cm | 27 | 43 | 48 : 52 | Myxoid liposarcoma only G1-G2: 66.6% G3: 33.3% | LE only | 13 cm | 5 x 5 Gy = 25 Gy CTV = GTV + 2cm transv.; +4cm long. PTV = CTV + 0.7-1cm | 37.5 Gy/ 56.3 Gy |
Kalbasi et al. [47] | 2020 USA | Phase II single center trial Localized extremity or trunk STS | 50 | <50: 28% 50-64: 22% 65-79: 40% >79: 10% | 44 : 56 | G1: 2 % G2: 38 % G3: 60 % | LE: 68% UE: 18% Trunk: 14% | 26% ≤5 cm 50% >5 - ≤10 cm 24% >10 cm: | 5 x 6 Gy = 30 Gy CTV = GTV + 1.5cm transv.; + 3cm long. PTV = CTV + 0.5cm | 50 Gy/75 Gy |
Parsai et al. [59] | 2020 USA | Retrosp. Analysis Localized extremity or trunk STS | 16 | 64 | 44 : 56 | G2: 50% G3: 18.8% Unknown: 31.2% | LE: 62.5% UE: 25% Trunk: 12.5% | 18.8% ≤5 cm 56.2% >5 - ≤10cm 18.8% >10 cm - ≤15 cm 6.2% >15 cm | n=1: 5 x 5 Gy = 25 Gy n=14: 5 x 6 Gy = 30 Gy n=1 5 x 8 Gy = 40 Gy Target volumes: according to RTOG-0630 [35] | n=1 37.5 Gy/ 56.3 Gy n=14 50 Gy/75 Gy n=1 80 Gy/120 Gy |
Pennington et al. [60] | 2018 USA | Retrosp. Analysis Localized, non-recurrent STS | 116 | 46 | 40 : 60 | G1: 0.9% G2: 13% G3: 79% Unknown: 7% | LE: 79% UE: 21% | 17% ≤5cm 35% >5 - ≤10 cm 47% >10 cm | 8 x 3.5 Gy = 28 Gy CTV = GTV + 4-5 cm long. PTV: N/A | 35 Gy/52.5 Gy |
RT modality | CTX | Time to surgery | Median FU (mths) | OS | LR | LC | LRFS | DFS | Acute toxicity | Late toxicity |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
3D-CRT > IMRT > VMAT | No | 7 weeks (median) | 27.1 | 25 of 27 pts (93%) | 0% | N/A | N/A | 100% 3 yrs G1-G2 50% 3 yrs G3 | Wound dehiscence: 10.3% Wound infection: 17.2% Dermatitis: 1°: 34.4% 2°: 3.4% 3°: 3.4% | 13.8 % Edema: 1°: 3.4% 2°: 3.4% Fibrosis °1: 3.4% °2: 3.4% |
3D-CRT 20 IMRT 76% IGRT 96% Electron 4% | No | 4 weeks (median) | 29 | 84% | 2 of 35 pts (5.7%) | N/A | N/A | N/A | Major WC: 32% Most common in LE °2 dermatitis: 8% | 1°: Fibrosis: 24% Stiffness: 11% Edema: 4% 2°: Fibrosis: 11% Stiffness: 11% Edema: 4% |
IMRT VMAT IGRT | N = 2 pts* | 1 day (median) | 10.7 | 87.5% | 0% | N/A | N/A | N/A | Major WC: 18.8% Minor WC: 12.5% | ≥3°: 0% |
3D-CRT | AI | 1-2 weeks | 5.9 yrs | 82% 3 yrs 67% 6 yrs | 11% 3 yrs 17% 6 yrs | N/A | N/A | N/A | Toxicity recorded for 17 pts: Acute WC: seromas/hematomas: 6 surgical site infection: 5 delayed wound healing: 1 |
Author | Year and country | Type of trial and Inclusion criteria | N | Median age (years) | Sex ratio (♀:♂ in %) | Histologic grade | Location | Median tumor dia- meter | Fraction and dose; target volume | EQD2/BEDα/β of 4 (Gy) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Kubicek et al. [61] | 2018 USA | Phase II single center trial Localized extremity STS | 13 | N/A, all patients > 18 yrs | N/A | G1-G2: 21.4% G3: 78.5% | LE: 71.4% UE: 14.3% Groin: 14.3% | 7.6 cm | Most pts: 5 x 7 Gy = 35 Gy 3 of 13 pts: 5 x 8 Gy = 40 Gy Median isodose line: 81% CTV = GTV + 0.5 cm radial; + 3 cm long. PTV= CTV + 0.5 cm | Most pts: 64.17 Gy/96.3 Gy 3 of 13 pts: 80 Gy/120 Gy |
Kılıç et al. [62] | 2017 Turkey | Retrosp. Analysis Localized, G2-G3 ≥ 4cm or G1 ≥ 8cm extremity STS | 67 | 47 | 43 : 57 | G2: 7.5% G3: 26.9 % Unknown: 65.6% | N/A | 9.6 cm | 8 x 3.5 Gy = 28 Gy PTV: N/A | 35 Gy/52.5 Gy |
Koseła-Paterczyk et al. [63] | 2016 Poland | Sub-analysis of (64) | 32 | 50 | 41 : 59 | Myxoid liposarcoma only G1: 15.6 % G2: 12.5 % G3: 46.9 % Unknown: 25% | LE: 97% UE: 3% | 10.5 cm | 53%: 5 x 5 Gy = 25 Gy 47%: 5 x 4 Gy = 20 Gy CTV = GTV + 2cm transv.; + 4cm long. PTV = CTV + 0.7-1cm | 53%: 37.5 Gy/ 56.3 Gy 47%: 26.67 Gy/40 Gy |
Koseła-Paterczyk et al. [64] | 2014 Poland | Phase II single center trial Locally advanced trunk wall or extremity G2-G3 STS or G1 if > 10cm diameter | 272 | 55 | 53 : 47 | G1: 11.8 % G2: 23.6 % G3: 64.6 % | LE: 70.2% UE: 16.2% Trunk: 13.6% | 8.5 cm | 5 x 5 Gy = 25 Gy CTV = GTV + 2cm transv.; + 4cm long. PTV = CTV + 0.7-1cm | 37.5 Gy/ 56.3 Gy |
RT modality | CTX | Time to surgery | Median FU (months) | OS | LR | LC | LRFS | DFS | Acute toxicity | Late toxicity |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
SBRT | 21.4%; agent N/A | 37 days (median) | 279 days | N/A | 7.7% | 93% | N/A | N/A | Major WC: 28.5 % | 0% |
N/A | 50% RT+AI vs. 50% RT alone | 2-3 Weeks after pre-op RT | 37 | 3yrs: 74.1% vs. 90.0% p=0.4 | 14.9% | N/A | 3 yrs: 77.1% vs. 76.3% p=0.86 | 3 yrs: 50.5% vs. 65.7% p=0.33 | N/A | N/A |
3D-CRT | No | 3-7 days | 60 | 68% 5 yrs | 9.3% | 90%# 5 yrs | N/A# | N/A | Acute:22 % = 7 patients 3 wound infection 2 wound dehiscence 5 prolonged healing Late: 9% = 3 patients 1 prolonged edema 2 tissue fibrosis No differences in RT regimens | |
3D-CRT IMRT for trunk lesions only (13.6%) | 22.4% substance N/A | 3-7 days | 35 | 72% 3 yrs | 19.1% | 81% 3yrs** | N/A** | N/A | Overall: 32.4%: Inflammation requiring antibiotic treatment: 11.8% Wound dehiscence: 11.8% Prolonged wound healing: 16.5% | Overall: 14.7% 1°-3° Fibrosis: 3.7% Edema: 9.2% |