Skip to main content

Table 4 Literature review of retrospective studies evaluating multi-fraction stereotactic radiosurgery

From: A multi-center analysis of single-fraction versus hypofractionated stereotactic radiosurgery for the treatment of brain metastasis

 

# patients; # lesions

Median f/u (mos)

Tumor size (cm3)

Median dose (BED10)

1-year LC

Symptomatic RN

Prior WBRT

Prior resection

Median BED > 50

 Minniti et al. [24]

135;171

11.4

10.1

9Gy × 3 (51.3) (≥2 cm)

12Gy ×  3 (79.2) (< 2 cm)

88%

6%

0

0

 Aoyama et al. [38]

87; 159

6.3

3.3

8.75 ×  4a (65.6)

81%

2.7%

0

0

 Ernst-Stecken et al. [16]

51; 72

7

13

7Gy × 5 (59.5) (n = 22)

6Gy ×  5 (w/ WBRT) (48) (n = 29)

76%

NS

NS

NS

 Fahrig et al. [17]

150; 228

28

6.1

5Gy × 7 (52.5) (n = 63)

7Gy × 5 (59.5Gy) (n = 51)

4Gy ×10 (56) (n = 36)

96%

87%

85%

NS

0

13%

 Ogura et al. [23]

39; 46

9.5

3.7

7Gy × 5 (59.5)

87%

2.5%

71%

0

 Manning et al. [20]

32; 57

9.2

2.2

9Gy × 3a (51.3)

91%

6%

NS

19%

 Jeong et al. [18]

37; 38

10

17.6

35Gy in 3/5 fxs (59–76)

87%

16%

0

0

 Inoue et al. [39]

78; 85

8

12.6

6.2Gy × 5 (50.2)

93%

2%

13%

0

 Navarria et al. [22]

102; 102

14

16.3

9Gy ×3 (51.3) (n = 51)

8Gy × 4 (57.6) (n = 51)

96%

6%

0

0

 Chon et al. [37]

38 lesions

14

NS

7Gy x5a

92%

5%

0

0

 Jeon et al. 2019 [46]

45; 52

10.5

14.2

8Gy × 3 (43) (n = 19)

9Gy × 3 (51.3) (n = 19)

10Gy ×  3(60) (n = 14)

77%/100%b

17.8%

0

0

Median BED <50Gy

 Marcrom et al. [40]

72; 182

5

2

5Gy × 5 (37.5) (n = 48 lesions)

6Gy ×  5 (48) (n = 134 lesions)

75%

91%

6%

7%

0

 Narayana et al. [41]

20 patients

NS

NS

6Gy × 5 (45)

70%

NS

0%

0

 Kwon et al. [19]

27; 52

6.6

0.5

5Gy x 5a (37.5Gy)

68%

5.8%

86%

0

  1. LC local control, RN radiation necrosis, WBRT whole-brain radiation therapy, NS not specified
  2. aMedian dose regimen
  3. bDaily treatment/every other day treatment