Skip to main content

Table 2 Mean values and the range of dosimetric data for the different treatment plans as planned and recalculated using

From: Developing and evaluating stereotactic lung RT trials: what we should know about the influence of inhomogeneity corrections on dose

 

CC

UD

   

EPL

   
 

Planned

Planned

p-value

Recalculated

p-value

Planned

p-value

recalculated

p-value

D95 [Gy]

60.0

60.0

-

56.9 [42.1–63.4]

0.007

60.0

-

48.0 [34.6–56.1]

< 0.001

D99 [Gy]

58.5 [57.6–59.5]

58.8 [57.8–59.8]

< 0.001

54.5 [39.6–62.0]

< 0.001

58.8 [58.1–59.7]

< 0.001

45.9 [32.6–53.7]

< 0.001

Disoc [Gy]

74.3 [66.0–84.1]

66.6 [62.5–71.3]

< 0.001

72.7 [59.3–79.6]

0.19

67.1 [63.2–72.2]

< 0.001

61.7 [47.9–70.1]

< 0.001

Dmean [Gy]

66.9 [64.1–71.0]

64.1 [61.6–66.6]

< 0.001

65.0 [49.1–71.0]

0.11

64.3 [61.8–66.4]

< 0.001

55.2 [39.7–62.1]

< 0.001

Dmax [Gy]

75.6 [67.8–87.4]

68.1 [63.0–73.3]

< 0.001

73.8 [61.3–81.7]

0.17

68.5 [63.8–76.5]

< 0.001

62.9 [48.0–74.2]

< 0.001

V100%/VPTV

1.13 [0.98–1.38]

1.09 [0.98–1.25]

0.14

0.98 [0.01–1.45]

0.08

1.09 [1.03–1.22]

0.026

0.27 [0.00–0.71]

< 0.001

V50%/VPTV

8.4 [4.5–18.2]

6.3 [4.4–12.6]

< 0.001

6.6 [4.9–12.2]

0.006

6.3 [4.1–12.0]

< 0.001

4.8 [3.1–6.5]

< 0.001

V20 Gy [%]

6.6 [2.9–16.7]

5.6 [2.2–14.2]

< 0.001

6.0 [2.3–15.5]

0.017

5.2 [2.1–12.3]

< 0.001

4.1 [1.5–10.9]

< 0.001

V10 Gy [%]

13.7 [7.3–35.8]

12.1 [5.9–29.9]

< 0.001

13.1 [6.1–33.5]

0.038

12.0 [5.5–29.5]

< 0.001

10.9 [4.6–27.3]

< 0.001

MLD [cGy]

456 [257–941]

396 [203–828]

< 0.001

439 [223–905]

0.18

394 [205–738]

< 0.001

355 [183–683]

< 0.001

  1. full inhomogeneity corrections, and the p-values for the paired-sample t-test comparing the UD and EPL calculated and recalculated plans to the CC plan.