Skip to main content

Table 1 Results of randomized phase III trials on hyperthermia for cancers in the head and neck

From: Status quo and directions in deep head and neck hyperthermia

Reference

Tumor

Combi

N

Endpoint(s)

-HT

+HT

Heating

Quality control

Valdagni et al. 1988 & 1994 [18, 19]

Neck Nodes

RT

44

CR

41 %

83 %

Radiative (280–300 MHz)

Invasive, > 4 each HT session (periphery:core = 4:1)

5 years LC

24 %

69 %

5 years OS

0 %

50 %

Datta et al. 1990 [21]

OC, OP (stage I–IV)

RT

65

CR

31 %

55 %

Capacitive, (27.12 kHz)

-

Huilgol et al. 2010 [22]

OC, OP, HP (stage II–IV)

RT

54

CR

42 %

79 %

Capacitive (8 MHz)

Invasive (infrequent)

Hua et al. 2011 [25]

NP (stage I–IV)

CRT

180

5 years LC

79 %

91 %

Conduction (resistive wire)

Nasal cavity internal skin temperature

5 years PFS

63 %

73 %

5 years OS

70 %

78 %

Zhao et al. 2014 [27]

NP (stage II–IV)

CRT

83

3-years OS (QoL)

54 %

73 %

Capacitive

Nasal cavity internal skin temperature

  1. RT Radiotherapy, CRT Chemo-radiotherapy, N total number of included patients in the study, −HT results without HT, +HT results with HT, LC local control, CR complete response, PFS progression free survival, OC oral cavity, OP oropharynx, HP hypopharynx, NP nasopharynx. Results in bold are significant at the 5 %-level. Toxicity was comparable in all randomized trials, although Zhao et al. found an improved quality of life (QoL)