Author | # Patients | Lesion Type | Dose/fraction (Fx) | Median Follow-up (months) | Local Control (years) | Overall Survival (years) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Timmerman [10] | 70 | T1-T2,N0M0 NSCLC | 60-66 Gy/3 Fx | 17.5 | 2-yr: 95 % | 2-yr: 54.7 % |
Milano [13] | 53 | Primary, Metastases | 30-63 Gy/2.5-5 Fx | 10 | 2-yr: 73 % | 2-yr: |
Stage I: 72 % | ||||||
Stage II-III:12 % | ||||||
Mets: 49 % | ||||||
Song [9] | 32 | Stage I NSCLC | 40-60 Gy/3-4 Fx | 26.5 | 2-yr: 85.3 % | 1-yr: 70.9 % |
2-yr: 38.5 % | ||||||
Unger [18] | 20 | Hilar lesions -Primary, Metastases | 30-40 Gy/5 Fx | 10 | 1-yr: 63 % | 1-yr: 54 % |
Haasbeek [12] | 63 | Stage I-II NSCLC | 60 Gy/8 Fx | 35 | 2-yr: 92.6 % | 2-yr: 69 % |
5-yr: 92.6 % | 5-yr: 49.5 % | |||||
Rowe [16] | 47 | Primary, Metastases | BED10: 60–151.2/3-5 Fx | 11.3 | 2-yr: 94 % | NA |
BED ≥ 100 Gy: 100 % | ||||||
BED < 100 Gy: 80 % | ||||||
Nuyttens [14] | 56 | Primary, Metastases | 45-60 Gy/5-6 Fx | 23 | 2-yr: 76 % | 2-yr: 60 % |
BED > 100: 85 % | 3-yr: 53 % | |||||
BED ≤ 100: 60 % | ||||||
Chang [11] | 100 | Primary, isolated recurrences | 50 Gy/4 Fx | 30.6 | 3-yr: 96.5 % | 3-yr: 70.5 % |
70 Gy/5 Fx | ||||||
Bahig [19] | 39 | T1-T2N0 NSCLC | Median BED10: 113 Gy (range 106–180 Gy) | 22 | 2-yr: 89 % | 2 yr: 74 % |
Schanne [17] | 90 | Stage I/II | 24 – 60 Gy/1-18 Fx | 18.8 | 1-yr: 76 % | 1-yr: 72 % |
2-yr: 64 % | 3-yr: 29 % | |||||
3-yr: 52 % | ||||||
Current study | 111 | T1-T2 NSCLC, Metastases | 20 – 60 Gy/1-5 Fx | 17 | 1-yr: 89 % | 2-yr: |
2-yr: 72 % | T1: 79 % | |||||
T2: 32.1 % | ||||||
Mets: 49.6 % |