Radiotherapy alone for stage I-III low grade follicular lymphoma: long-term outcome and comparison of extended field and total nodal irradiation
© Guckenberger et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2012
Received: 16 April 2012
Accepted: 17 June 2012
Published: 24 June 2012
To analyze long-term results of radiotherapy alone for stage I-III low grade follicular lymphoma and to compare outcome after extended field irradiation (EFI) and total nodal irradiation (TNI).
Methods and materials
Between 1982 and 2007, 107 patients were treated with radiotherapy alone for low grade follicular lymphoma at Ann Arbor stage I (n = 50), II (n = 36) and III (n = 21); 48 and 59 patients were treated with EFI and TNI, respectively. The median total dose in the first treatment series of the diaphragmatic side with larger lymphoma burden was 38 Gy (25 Gy – 50 Gy) and after an interval of median 30 days, a total dose of 28 Gy (12.6 Gy – 45 Gy) was given in the second treatment series completing TNI.
After a median follow-up of 14 years for living patients, 10-years and 15-years overall survival (OS) were 64% and 50%, respectively. Survival was not significantly different between stages I, II and III. TNI and EFI resulted in 15-years OS of 65% and 34% but patients treated with TNI were younger, had better performance status and higher stage of disease compared to patients treated with EFI. In multivariate analysis, only age at diagnosis (p < 0.001, relative risk [RR] 1.06) and Karnofsky performance status (p = 0.04, RR = 0.96) were significantly correlated with OS. Freedom from progression (FFP) was 58% and 56% after 10-years and 15-years, respectively. Recurrences outside the irradiated volume were significantly reduced after TNI compared to EFI; however, increased rates of in-field recurrences and extra-nodal out-of-field recurrence counterbalanced this effect resulting in no significant difference in FFP between TNI and EFI. In univariate analysis, FFP was significantly improved in stage I compared to stage II but no differences were observed between stages I/II and stage III. In multivariate analysis no patient or treatment parameter was correlated with FFP. Acute toxicity was significantly increased after TNI compared to EFI with a trend to increased late toxicity as well.
Radiotherapy alone for stage I and II follicular lymphoma resulted in long-term OS with high rates of disease control; no benefit of TNI over EFI was observed. For stage III follicular lymphoma, TNI achieved promising OS and FFP and should be considered as a potentially curative treatment option.
KeywordsFollicular lymphoma Total nodal irradiation Extended field irradiation
Follicular lymphoma (FL) is after diffuse large B-cell lymphoma the second most common subtype of non-Hodgkin’s lymphomas in adults (~ 20–25%). Radiotherapy alone is an established curative treatment option for patients with stage I-II FL [1–3]. However, the volume, which needs to be irradiated, is still an issue of controversy. As the site of treatment failure is most frequently nodal outside irradiated involved volumes, extended-field irradiation (EFI) or even total nodal irradiation (TNI) have been proposed to improve outcome compared to involved-field irradiation (IFI). While studies reported improved progression free survival (PFS) after treatment of larger volumes, this did not transfer into improved overall survival (OS) [4, 5]. Despite the majority of relapses are observed within 5 years after radiotherapy, late recurrences 15 – 20 years after treatment [4–6] indicate the need for studies with long-term follow-up, which are scarce in the literature.
Stage III disease is considered as non-curative and chemotherapy or wait and see strategies are most frequently perused. Nevertheless, studies reported promising disease control and overall survival rates after radiotherapy alone for stage III FL [7, 8]. Recent data reported that lower radiation doses are sufficient for disease control , which might further reduce acute and especially long term toxicity. In this context of potentially reduced toxicity, radiotherapy in form of TNI might become a more attractive treatment strategy for advanced stage of disease. It was consequently the aim of this retrospective single institution study to describe long-term outcome after radiotherapy alone for stage I-III FL and to compare patterns of failure and OS after EFI and TNI.
Material and methods
Between 1982 and 2007, 107 patients were treated with radiotherapy alone for low grade follicular lymphoma. Of these 107 patients, Ann Arbor stage was I (n = 50), II (n = 36) and III (n = 21). Ann Arbor stage was based on contrast enhanced whole body CT imaging and bone marrow biopsy in all patients.
All patients were treated with radiotherapy alone as primary treatment; patients who received chemotherapy as part of the primary treatment were excluded from this analysis. Patients were treated with either EFI of all central lymph node regions on the involved side of the diaphragm (supra-diaphragmatic: cervical, supra- and infraclavicular, mediastinal and hilar; infra-diaphragmatic: paraaortal, iliacal, inguinal) or with TNI (sequential supra-diaphragmatic and infra-diaphragmatic irradiation). Treatment was always started at the diaphragmatic side with higher lymphoma burden (first series) followed by the side with lower lymphoma burden or elective irradiation (second series). Total lymphatic irradiation with routine treatment of the Waldeyer’s tonsillar ring and mesenteric lymph nodes was not practiced. The spleen and Waldeyer's tonsillar ring were irradiated in 12% and 36% of the patients, respectively. Single fraction doses ranged between 1.5 Gy −2.0 Gy with the majority of patients treated with 1.8 Gy or 2.0 Gy. Lymph node regions without macroscopic involvement were treated with a total dose of 30 Gy and a boost of 6 - 8 Gy was given to macroscopic involved lymph node regions: the median total dose in the first treatment series was 38 Gy (25 Gy – 50 Gy) and after a median interval of 30 days, a total dose of 28 Gy (12.6 Gy – 45 Gy) was given in the second treatment series.
Patient and treatment characteristics were compared between the two groups treated with EFI and TNI and between stage I/II and stage III using Chi-squared test for categorical variables and Mann-Withney U-test for continuous variables using Statistica X software (Statsoft, Tulsa, OK, USA). Survival and recurrence data were calculated by the Kaplan–Meier method: overall survival (OS) and freedom from progression (FFP) were calculated. Results between subgroups were compared using the log-rank test and the influence of patient and treatment factors on OS and FFP was evaluated using the multivariate Cox proportional-hazards regression model with backward exclusion of non-significant variables. Results with p < 0.05 were considered as statistically significant.
Patient and treatment characteristics with comparison between EFI and TNI and between stages I/II and stage III disease
26 - 83
37 - 83
26 - 74
27 – 83
26 - 68
Karnofsky Performance status
50 - 100
50 - 100
80 - 100
50 – 100
70 – 100
Ann Arbor stage
Bulk ≥7.5 cm
Radiotherapy dose median/range [Gy]
25 - 50
27 - 50
25 - 46
25 - 50
29 - 46
Distribution of involved lymph node regions separately for patients with stage I, stage II and stage III follicular lymphoma
Stage I (n = 50)
Stage II (n = 36)
Stag III (n = 21)
The median number of involved lymph node regions was 2 (range 2–5) and 4 (range 2–11) in stage II and III disease, respectively. Patients at stage III were younger compared to stage I/II and elevated LDH was observed more frequently in stage III patients; there were no difference in the rate of bulky disease and irradiation doses. Of patients with stage III disease, 18/21 were treated with TNI; one patient denied infra-diaphragmatic after supra-diaphragmatic irradiation and the reason for two patients is unknown.
Median follow-up was 10 years for all patients (0.3 – 26 years) and 14 years (2–26 years) for living patients. Follow-up was not different between EFI and TNI and between stages I/II and stage III.
Univariate and multivariate analysis of patient and treatment factors influencing overall survival and freedom from disease progression
Freedom from disease progression
p = 0.0001
p = 0.0001
RR = 1.06
Karnofsky performance status
p = 0.0003
P = 0.04
RR = 0.96
Stage of disease
P = 0.001
TNI vs EFI
p = 0.001
A total of 35 recurrences were observed with crude rates of 33% and 32% after EFI and TNI, respectively. 14/16 (87.5%) and 8/19 (42%) of the recurrences after EFI and TNI were located outside the irradiated volume, which was highly significant (p = 0.01).
During the first irradiation series, 5 patients (5%) developed acute toxicity grade III (gastrointestinal mucositis n = 4; nausea and vomiting n = 1). During the second irradiation series in TNI patients, acute toxicity was significantly increased with 1 patient (2%) developing grade IV toxicity (thrombocytopenia) and 8 patients (14%) suffering from grade III toxicity (leukopenia n = 3, thrombocytopenia n = 2, gastrointestinal mucositis n = 2, nausea and vomiting n = 1).
Late toxicity was maximum grade II in all patients and grade II toxicity was observed in 27 patients (25%). The most frequent grade II toxicity was pulmonary (n = 12; pulmonary fibrosis, dyspnoea, cough) and gastro-intestinal (n = 9; dry mouth, dysphagia, dental, hepatitis, colitis). Two patients developed chronic haematological toxicity and one patient generalized dry skin and fatigue. Any grade II toxicity was increased after TNI (n = 18; 31%) compared to EFI (n = 8; 17%) but this difference did not reach statistical significance.
This study confirms previous data, that treatment of larger irradiation fields does not improve overall survival in stage I and II follicular lymphoma. Wilder et al. reported the M.D. Anderson experience of 80 patients treated with IFI (9%), regional RT (54%; treatment of 1–3 adjacent, grossly uninvolved nodal regions) or EFI (37%); TNI irradiation was not practiced . After a median follow-up of 19 years for living patients, no difference in OS was observed between EFI and IFI/regional RT: 49% versus 40% at 15 years. Recurrences were more frequently observed in patients treated with EFI; however, there were imbalances of stage distribution and total irradiation dose and no multivariate analysis was performed. Mac Manus et al. described the Stanford experience of 177 patients and differentiated between irradiation of the involved side or both sides of the diaphragm . After a median follow-up of 7.7 years, FFP at 10 year were 36% and 67% for treatment of the involved side only and both sides of the diaphragm, respectively, which was highly significant. However, this improvement in disease control did not transfer into increased OS.
In our own study, evaluating the impact of TNI and EFI on FFP and OS was difficult because of a correlation between the target volume concept and established prognostic parameters: age of the patients, performance status and stage of disease. No difference of FFP was observed between TNI and EFI in univariate and multivariate analysis. In agreement to Stuschke et al. , irradiation of uninvolved lymph node regions with a median dose of 30 Gy was effective in reducing out-of-field recurrences. However, an increased rate of in-field recurrences and extra-nodal out-of-field recurrence counterbalanced this beneficial effect of TNI. Regarding OS, patients treated with TNI were younger and had a better performance status and as a consequence, 15-years OS was 65% and 34% after TNI and EFI, respectively. However, only age and Karnofsky performance status and not the target volume concept remained statistically significant in multivariate analysis.
The 10-years OS of 64% for the patient population with stages I/II disease is considered as representative for early stage follicular lymphoma because our department is the only radiotherapy centre within a radius of minimum 50 – 100 km and rather strict referral patters in the geographical region; a potential patient selection bias is consequently limited. The observed OS is in good agreement with published data in the literature about primary radiotherapy for stages I/II follicular lymphoma: two recent literature reviews reported 10-years OS rates ranging between 46% and 79% (weighted average of 63% in Heinzelmann et al.) after primary radiotherapy using mostly IFI or EFI [11, 12]. No obvious correlation of OS and irradiated volume is seen in this literature review. This further supports the hypothesis of no OS benefit after TNI.
The larger treatment volumes of TNI came at the price of increased toxicity. While the first series of EFI irradiation was well tolerated with only 5% of the patients developing grade III toxicity, 16% of the patients suffered from acute toxicity grade ≥ III during the second series, which completed the TNI. Additionally, chronic toxicity grade II was observed more frequently after TNI (31%) compared to EFI (17%).
Randomized data about the question of the appropriate irradiation volume are missing. A German multicentre phase III trial, which randomized between TNI and EFI, closed in 2007 and final results are awaited. Until results of this trial are available, increased acute and chronic toxicity with no apparent benefit in terms of survival and disease control as observed in this study do not support the concept of TNI compared to EFI for stage I and II FL.
Twenty one patients with stage III FL were treated with radiotherapy alone and were included into this study. Unfortunately, prognostic factors were not fully balanced between stages I/II and stage III. Patients at stage III FL were younger indicating that age was a selection criterion for radiotherapy alone in stage III patients. As expected based on the increased lymphoma burden, LDH was more frequently elevated in stage III patients. TNI was the planned treatment in all stage III patients and was successfully completed in almost 90% of the patients.
Outcome was favourable with 10-years OS and FFP of 61% and 62%, respectively. OS and FFP were not significantly different to stages I/II. This favourable outcome is in good agreement with data in the literature [7, 8, 13, 14], where 10-years OS ranged between 47% and 65%. Only a small number of patients with stage III disease was at risk after 10 years in our study; however, the Stanford experience of 66 stage III patients treated with radiotherapy alone described no disease recurrence after 10 years and only 5/29 lymphoma deaths after 10 years . These data are promising especially in the light of the recently published British trial, which showed that radiotherapy doses for indolent lymphomas can be reduced without negatively affecting clinical outcome. Consequently, TNI with reduced irradiation may have the potential of long term disease control and survival with simultaneously decreased acute and chronic toxicity . Of course, such concepts need to be validated within clinical trials.
Some limitations of our study need to be discussed. The retrospective nature of this study is associated with well-known limitations. The decision making process between EFI and TNI considered well established prognostic factors like age, performance status and stage of FL, which made the statistical comparison of the two target volume concepts difficult. Additionally, the reconstruction of the decision making process in favour of radiotherapy and against chemotherapy in stage III FL could not be fully reconstructed: the ratio of stage I + II : stage III patients in the International Lymphoma classification project was 2:1  compared to 4:1 in our study, which suggests some selection process for radiotherapy.
Radiotherapy alone for stage I and II follicular lymphoma was an effective and curative treatment with high rates of disease control. Larger irradiation fields covering both sides of the diaphragm did not improve tumor control and overall survival. Additionally, TNI was associated with increased rates of acute and chronic toxicity. Based on this study and data from the literature, EFI or IFI are the preferred treatments for stage I and II follicular lymphoma. In patients with stage III FL, TNI resulted in promising tumor control and overall survival and should be considered as a potentially curative treatment option.
This publication was funded by the German Research Foundation (DFG) and the University of Wuerzburg in the funding programme Open Access Publishing.
- Kelsey SM, Newland AC, Hudson GV, Jelliffe AM: A British National Lymphoma Investigation randomised trial of single agent chlorambucil plus radiotherapy versus radiotherapy alone in low grade, localised non-Hodgkins lymphoma. Med Oncol 1994,11(1):19-25. 10.1007/BF02990087View ArticlePubMed
- Pugh TJ, Ballonoff A, Newman F, Rabinovitch R: Improved survival in patients with early stage low-grade follicular lymphoma treated with radiation: a Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results database analysis. Cancer 2010,116(16):3843-3851. 10.1002/cncr.25149View ArticlePubMed
- Nissen NI, Ersboll J, Hansen HS, Walbom-Jorgensen S, Pedersen-Bjergaard J, Hansen MM, Rygard J: A randomized study of radiotherapy versus radiotherapy plus chemotherapy in stage I-II non-Hodgkin’s lymphomas. Cancer 1983,52(1):1-7.View ArticlePubMed
- Mac Manus MP, Hoppe RT: Is radiotherapy curative for stage I and II low-grade follicular lymphoma? Results of a long-term follow-up study of patients treated at Stanford University. Journal of clinical oncology : official journal of the American Society of Clinical Oncology 1996,14(4):1282-1290.
- Wilder RB, Jones D, Tucker SL, Fuller LM, Ha CS, McLaughlin P, Hess MA, Cabanillas F, Cox JD: Long-term results with radiotherapy for Stage I-II follicular lymphomas. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 2001,51(5):1219-1227. 10.1016/S0360-3016(01)01747-3View ArticlePubMed
- Guadagnolo BA, Li S, Neuberg D, Ng A, Hua L, Silver B, Stevenson MA, Mauch P: Long-term outcome and mortality trends in early-stage, Grade 1–2 follicular lymphoma treated with radiation therapy. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 2006,64(3):928-934. 10.1016/j.ijrobp.2005.08.010View ArticlePubMed
- Jacobs JP, Murray KJ, Schultz CJ, Wilson JF, Goswitz MS, Stevens CW, Cox JD: Central lymphatic irradiation for stage III nodular malignant lymphoma: long-term results. Journal of clinical oncology : official journal of the American Society of Clinical Oncology 1993,11(2):233-238.
- Murtha AD, Rupnow BA, Hansosn J, Knox SJ, Hoppe R: Long-term follow-up of patients with Stage III follicular lymphoma treated with primary radiotherapy at Stanford University. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 2001,49(1):3-15. 10.1016/S0360-3016(00)00780-XView ArticlePubMed
- Lowry L, Smith P, Qian W, Falk S, Benstead K, Illidge T, Linch D, Robinson M, Jack A, Hoskin P: Reduced dose radiotherapy for local control in non-Hodgkin lymphoma: a randomised phase III trial. Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology 2011,100(1):86-92. 10.1016/j.radonc.2011.05.013View Article
- Stuschke M, Hoederath A, Sack H, Potter R, Muller RP, Schulz U, Karstens J, Makoski HB: Extended field and total central lymphatic radiotherapy in the treatment of early stage lymph node centroblastic-centrocytic lymphomas: results of a prospective multicenter study, Study Group NHL-fruhe Stadien. Cancer 1997,80(12):2273-2284. 10.1002/(SICI)1097-0142(19971215)80:12<2273::AID-CNCR9>3.0.CO;2-VView ArticlePubMed
- Eich HT, Heimann M, Stutzer H, Kriz J, Reiser M, Muller RP: Long-term outcome and prognostic factors in early-stage nodal low-grade non-hodgkin's lymphomas treated with radiation therapy. Strahlentherapie und Onkologie : Organ der Deutschen Rontgengesellschaft [et al] 2009,185(5):288-295. 10.1007/s00066-009-1937-4View Article
- Heinzelmann F, Engelhard M, Ottinger H, Bamberg M, Weinmann M: Nodal follicular lymphoma: the role of radiotherapy for stages I and II. Strahlentherapie und Onkologie : Organ der Deutschen Rontgengesellschaft [et al] 2010,186(4):191-196. 10.1007/s00066-010-2090-9View Article
- Paryani SB, Hoppe RT, Cox RS, Colby TV, Kaplan HS: The role of radiation therapy in the management of stage III follicular lymphomas. Journal of clinical oncology : official journal of the American Society of Clinical Oncology 1984,2(7):841-848.
- Ha CS, Kong JS, McLaughlin P, Tucker SL, Fayad LE, Hess MA, Wilder RB, Cabanillas F, Cox JD: Stage III follicular lymphoma: long-term follow-up and patterns of failure. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 2003,57(3):748-754. 10.1016/S0360-3016(03)00641-2View ArticlePubMed
- Armitage JO, Weisenburger DD: New approach to classifying non-Hodgkin’s lymphomas: clinical features of the major histologic subtypes, Non-Hodgkin’s Lymphoma Classification Project. Journal of clinical oncology : official journal of the American Society of Clinical Oncology 1998,16(8):2780-2795.
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.